top of page
  • Denis Pepin

Understanding the Belief in Donald Trump's Lies and the Imperative of Truth

Updated: Mar 31

Donald Trump, the former president of the United States, has made false statements about various aspects of his life, including personal matters, business dealings, political achievements, adversaries, and even the country itself. He has also disseminated misinformation regarding critical issues such as the coronavirus pandemic, the 2020 election, the January 6 insurrection, and numerous other subjects. His falsehoods have been directed towards his supporters, allies, and the global audience. The sheer volume of his lies has, regrettably, led some individuals to lose track of the truth, and in some instances, resulted in real-world harm.


The question of why some people continue to believe Donald Trump's falsehoods, despite the existence of overwhelming evidence and rigorous fact-checking that refutes them, is a complex one. However, plausible explanations can be found within the realms of psychology, neuroscience, and sociology, which delve into the intricacies of human cognition, perception, and social dynamics.


Psychology, the study of human behavior and the mind, offers insights into this phenomenon. One psychological factor contributing to belief in Trump's lies is confirmation bias. This bias entails individuals seeking, interpreting, and recalling information that aligns with their existing beliefs. Trump's false statements often resonate with the emotions and grievances of his supporters, causing them to dismiss or ignore contradictory evidence. For example, his false claims about the severity of the coronavirus and the efficacy of vaccines, along with promotion of unproven treatments and conspiracy theories, led some of his followers to reject public health measures, risking their own and others' health.

 Neuroscience, which explores the workings of the brain and nervous system, provides another perspective. One relevant neuroscientific concept is source amnesia, which refers to the inability to remember the origin of information. Trump's falsehoods are frequently repeated and amplified by conservative media outlets, presenting them as facts without providing supporting evidence or context. These outlets often employ catchy slogans, headlines, and graphics to make his lies more memorable and persuasive. As a result, some supporters may forget or disregard the original source or context, only retaining the information itself. For example, his false claims about the 2020 election led to the storming of the Capitol on January 6, 2021, by supporters who believed the election had been stolen.


Sociology, the study of society and social interactions, offers additional insights. One sociological factor contributing to belief in Trump's falsehoods is social norms. Trump's lies often find endorsement among his followers, fostering a strong sense of identity and loyalty to him and his movement. This can lead individuals to conform to the group's beliefs, resist external criticism or challenges, and sometimes even engage in harassment or violence against perceived opponents. For example, Trump's false allegations against political rivals like Hillary Clinton, Barack Obama, Joe Biden, and Kamala Harris prompted some supporters to harbor extreme animosity, with potential consequences for public safety.


These are some potential explanations for why some people believe Donald Trump's falsehoods, grounded in the disciplines of psychology, neuroscience, and sociology. However, these are not exhaustive, and other factors may also influence individuals' beliefs and actions. It is essential to seek and defend the truth, even when it may be challenging to find or accept.


Why should people refrain from believing Donald Trump's falsehoods? Numerous compelling reasons exist, including the following:


1. Believing Donald Trump's falsehoods can have adverse consequences for individuals and society. As previously discussed, some of his false claims have resulted in real-world harm, such as the spread of COVID-19, the attack on the Capitol, and violence against his opponents. These falsehoods have led to death, injury, illness, and damage to property, as well as threats to public health, safety, and security.


2. Believing Donald Trump's falsehoods can undermine the foundations of democracy and the rule of law. As discussed earlier, some of his false claims have challenged the integrity and legitimacy of crucial institutions, eroding public trust in government, the judicial system, and the media. These falsehoods have also posed a threat to the peaceful transfer of power and the stability of the political system.


3. Believing Donald Trump's falsehoods can distort individuals' understanding of reality and the truth. As mentioned previously, his lies have created a distorted and misleading narrative of important events and issues. This distortion prevents people from accessing and comprehending the facts and evidence necessary for making informed and rational decisions. It also manipulates emotions and opinions, influencing actions and behaviors.


These are just some of the compelling reasons why people should be cautious about accepting Donald Trump's falsehoods. The pursuit of truth is essential, as it forms the basis of knowledge, wisdom, and justice. Truth serves as the guiding light in times of uncertainty and confusion, and it upholds the principles of transparency and accountability.


bottom of page